Many things have transpired at Eleanor West’s Home for Wayward Children since I read the debut novella, Every Heart a Doorway, but I did not feel lost at all. My thanks to Seanan McGuire for making subsequent installments of her series inviting even to people who do not hang on its every word. The Home is a haven for children who have had doors open for them into other worlds, worlds in which they were heroes, worlds which subsequently sent them back to this mundane order where they are hopelessly out of place and yearn for a way back. The Home gives some of them hope, all of them understanding, and many of them peers among fellow returnees.
Come Tumbling Down opens in the basement room that formerly belonged to Jack (short for Jacqueline), a student who, along with her twin sister Jill (short for Jillian), found her way back to the other world. Christopher, whose room it is now, was down there dreading the time when he will be too old for the school and longing for his Skeleton Girl and the Country of Bones, when the overhead light “flickered again before spitting a great, uneven bolt of lightning that struck the concrete floor with a crack so loud it was like the whole world was being broken.” (Ch. 1) Not the whole world but the gap between two worlds. Jack is back from the Moors, and in dire condition.
Well, not exactly Jack. Jack in Jill’s body, though the only student who recognizes that is Sumi, hero of Beneath the Sugar Sky. Sumi went to a Nonsense world called Confection and, as another character observes, it left her a little bit scrambled. “‘Dying scrambled me more,’ said Sumi matter-of-factly” (Ch. 2) which sums her up nicely.